If you’ve ever daydreamed about owning a home with a ghost story attached—or you’re the type who wants your house to come with a little supernatural flair—this guide is for you. After living in South Florida for over 30 years and working as a realtor here, I’ve seen the market, heard the rumors, and even experienced a few unexplainable things myself. In this article I’ll walk you through the top haunted cities in Florida where you’re most likely to stumble on a haunted house, share personal anecdotes and realtor tips, and give you practical advice on buying, researching, and living in one of these spooky properties.

Table of Contents

• Why Florida—What Makes These Haunted Cities in Florida So Special?
• My Experience: A Realtor’s Strange Showing
• How to Use This Guide
• St. Augustine
• Cassadaga
• Key West
• Ybor City — Tampa
• Miami
• Other Haunted Places Worth Mentioning
• Practical Advice for Buying in Haunted Cities in Florida
• Living in a Haunted Home—Tips to Coexist
• FAQs About Haunted Cities in Florida
• Final Thoughts: Is Buying in the Haunted Cities in Florida Right for You?
• Resources & Next Steps

Why Florida—What Makes These Haunted Cities in Florida So Special?

Florida ranks among the top states in the U.S. for reported paranormal activity. From centuries-old colonial towns to eccentric island communities, our state has a unique combination of long histories, mass migrations, shipwrecks, military actions, cemeteries, and cultural crossroads that generate stories people carry forward. That history makes the phrase “haunted cities in Florida” more than a gimmick—it’s part tourism, part local lore, and part real estate curiosity.

Two practical truths you should know right away: first, sellers in Florida are not legally required to disclose whether a house is haunted or whether a death occurred in the home (including suicide or homicide). Second, the value of a property can be affected by its reputation—positively or negatively—depending on the buyer. That’s where a realtor’s role becomes helpful: to find out the facts, advise on inspections and pricing, and help you decide whether the house’s ghost story is a deal-breaker—or a unique selling point.

My Experience: A Realtor’s Strange Showing

Before we dive into the list, a quick personal story. I once listed a historic home in a beautiful older neighborhood. Everything checked out on paper—great bones, original details, prime location. But buyers backed out three times, sometimes forfeiting escrow. Feedback ranged from “It felt like something was watching us” to a bizarre report that “water poured out of all the electrical sockets.” We sent plumbers and electricians. They found nothing.

Agents who held open houses reported odd sensations. The house eventually sold, and after the sale the new owners never reported anything to me. Was it paranormal? Maybe. Was it enough to scare buyers away? Absolutely. That experience taught me that a property’s reputation for being one of the “haunted cities in Florida” can affect buyer psychology just as much as a cracked foundation or a leaky roof.

How to Use This Guide

I compiled this list with two goals: to highlight the cities most associated with hauntings and to give you actionable tips if you’re considering buying in these areas. I’ll cover five cities in detail: St. Augustine, Cassadaga, Key West, Ybor City (Tampa), and Miami. Each city section includes notable haunted places, local color, and a realtor tip tailored to that neighborhood.

St. Augustine

St. Augustine tops my list if you want a haunted historic home. Founded in 1565, it’s the oldest continuously occupied European-established settlement in the United States. That long and layered history creates a deep well of stories and, yes, a robust ghost-tour industry.

Why St. Augustine ranks among the most famous haunted cities in Florida:

• Centuries of colonial history and conflict (Spanish, British, early American) mean plenty of old buildings, battle stories, and historic cemeteries.
• Preservation of Victorian and colonial homes makes it easy to find residences with documented pasts and well-known stories attached.
• Active tourism industry built around ghost tours, historic inns, and museums that highlight the supernatural.

Notable haunted spots in St. Augustine:

• St. Francis Inn: Over 300 years of reported activity; guests and staff have reported phantom voices, apparitions, and unexplained phenomena.
• Old Jail and Old Store: Frequent stops on ghost tours where visitors report cold spots and faint whispers.
• Huguenot Cemetery House: An example of how a house near a cemetery is often tied to ghost stories—locals believe spirits wander from the graves into nearby structures.
• Other houses: Andrew Young House, Segui-Kirby Smith House, The Treason House, Ximenez-Fatio House, and several properties in the Dow Museum complex—all carry stories that attract paranormal enthusiasts.

Realtor tip for St. Augustin  e: If you want a haunted historic home, research the local historical society records and attend a ghost tour. Ask neighbors and check old newspapers for incidents. If you’re superstitious (or just curious), a day-and-night visit can tell you more than photos ever will.

Cassadaga

Cassadaga bills itself as the “Psychic Capital of the World,” and it’s easy to see why. Founded in the late 19th century by trance medium George Colby, Cassadaga is an intentional spiritualist community north of Volusia where mediums and spiritual seekers established a town devoted to connecting with the other side.

This place isn’t just folklore; it’s a living community. People come for readings, spiritual retreats, and a culture that welcomes the paranormal. If you picture a town where ghostly activity is embraced rather than feared, Cassadaga fits that image perfectly.

Key haunted highlights in Cassadaga:

• Andrews House (built 1909): Reported shadows, unexplained footsteps, and cold spots. Mediums have claimed to sense spirits and even communicate with them.
• Many resident mediums maintain records of encounters; local shops and reading rooms offer both historical context and modern spiritual services.

Realtor tip for Cassadaga: If you’re buying in Cassadaga, be upfront about your interest in the town’s spiritual culture. Some buyers are drawn to the community’s identity; others are not. Also check zoning and community rules—Cassadaga’s status as an intentional spiritualist community affects property uses and local events.

Key West

Key West is famous for its sunsets, local characters, and ghost stories. It’s an island with an outsized personality—lush tourism, artists, and a history of storms, shipwrecks, and seafaring that gives rise to ghost tales. Key West ranks among the haunted cities in Florida not only for its number of stories but for how those stories have become local legend.

Places to know in Key West:

• The Artist House: Home of Robert Eugene Otto and the infamous doll “Robert.” The doll allegedly moves on its own and brings misfortune to those who disrespect it. Visitors claim disembodied laughter and objects moving.
• Audubon House and Tropical Gardens: Guests report the ghost of Captain Jack Geiger, footsteps, and objects that move by themselves.
• Other spots: Key West Cemetery, the East and West Martello Towers, the Oldest House, and Captain Tony’s Saloon—each with a mix of colorful history and supernatural lore.

Realtor tip for Key West: Buying near a cemetery or on land with indigenous burial grounds increases your chance of ending up with a house that’s called haunted. If you’re buying in Key West, research the lot history, and consider how tourism might affect your privacy—ghost tours can bring crowds to historically haunted homes.

Ybor City — Tampa

Ybor City is Tampa’s historic neighborhood famous for cigar factories, immigrant culture, and lively nightlife. It’s also a place with a rich catalog of ghost stories. Built on industry and immigrant experience, Ybor’s old social clubs, theaters, and factories provide the perfect backdrop for hauntings.

Haunted highlights in Ybor City:

• The Cuban Club (Built 1917): This ornate building served as a social club for Cuban immigrants and is reported to have disembodied voices, shadow figures, and cold drafts in empty rooms.
• Ybor City Museum State Park (Ferlita Bakery building): Locals report the scent of fresh bread, phantom footsteps, and a baker in period clothing.
• Other haunted places include the Italian Club, the Ritz Ybor (a music venue), the Orpheum Theater, Oliva Cigar Factory, and the old Florida Brewing Company Building.

Realtor tip for Ybor City: If you want the vibe—cigars, craft beer, carbs, and ghost stories—this neighborhood is an excellent investment. But check renovation histories for old buildings; many have been repurposed multiple times and may have environmental or structural issues. Factor those into your inspection process.

Miami

When people think of Miami they imagine glitz, glamour, and influence from Latin America. But Miami also has a surprising number of haunted properties, from Mediterranean revival landmarks to waterfront estates and historic theaters. Miami ranks among the haunted cities in Florida because of its high-profile haunted landmarks and the sheer variety of reported phenomena.

Notable haunted places in Miami:

• The Biltmore Hotel (built 1926): This iconic landmark has hosted royalty and celebrities—and reportedly hosts ghostly apparitions, unexplained voices, and other phenomena. It’s frequently featured on ghost-hunting shows.
• Villa Paula Mansion (Little Haiti): A Victorian-era mansion reportedly haunted by the spirit of Paula Milord.
• Deering Estate (South Miami): Waterfront property with reports of apparitions, disembodied voices, and cold spots.
• Other sites: Vizcaya Museum and Gardens, Miami City Cemetery, Freedom Tower (haunted by stories tied to Cuban refugees), and the Olympia Theater.

Realtor tip for Miami: Properties in historic and cultural neighborhoods can come with ghost stories attached. Knowing the story can help you market the home (some buyers love the lore) or prepare for negotiations (some buyers will shy away). Also, practical matters like flood zones, insurance, and preservation ordinances are especially important in Miami.

Other Haunted Places Worth Mentioning

Florida is full of other haunted sites beyond the top five cities. Here are a few you might want to explore if you’re on the hunt for haunted properties or just like spooky road trips:

• Bellaire Beach Club: Reported strange occurrences and a dark past in a beachfront setting.
• May-Stringer House (Brooksville): A historic home with long-standing ghost stories.
• Riddle House (West Palm Beach): Featured in paranormal lore and local ghost tours.
• Smaller towns and old plantation sites often have stories tied to local history, and you can find ghost tales in nearly every county in the state.

Practical Advice for Buying in Haunted Cities in Florida

Thinking of moving to one of the haunted cities in Florida? Here’s a step-by-step checklist to guide you through the process safely and smartly.

1. Do your research: Look up property history, obituaries, newspaper archives, and local historical society records. A quick search can uncover the events behind a spooky story.
2. Talk to neighbors and local agents: They often know the backstory and how the market reacts to a haunted reputation. Ask about past showings and whether any buyers were scared away.
3. Get thorough inspections: A haunted reputation might mask real issues (plumbing, electrical, mold). Make sure a qualified inspector checks everything.
4. Consider insurance and liability: Standard homeowner’s insurance won’t care if a house is “haunted,” but you may want to confirm coverage for unusual damages and ensure there are no easements or legal encumbrances tied to the property’s past.
5. Factor in resale: If you plan to flip or resell, understand your local market and whether buyers there appreciate historic character—or avoid it because of ghost stories.
6. Respect local culture: Some neighborhoods treat their haunted lore as a heritage asset. If you’re buying there, being respectful (and learning local customs) can go a long way.

Living in a Haunted Home—Tips to Coexist

If you buy a home that has a reputation for hauntings, here are practical steps to make coexisting easier, whether you’re a skeptic or a believer.

• Visit multiple times: Spend time in the house at different times of day. Some “phenomena” are simply the house settling, wildlife, or old plumbing making noises.
• Document strange occurrences: Keep a notebook with dates and descriptions. Sometimes patterns reveal rational causes.
• Maintain the property: Good maintenance reduces many “unexplained” problems—soundproofing, weatherproofing, fixing drafts, and eliminating vermin can solve a lot.
• Set personal boundaries: If you’re uneasy, rituals that comfort you—cultural, religious, or symbolic—can help you feel in control. As I joked in the video: in Miami, learning a little Spanish and sharing pastelitos might help make peace with the house’s history.
• Be mindful of visitors: Haunted homes attract curiosity. Consider privacy measures to control tours or unwanted attention.

FAQs About Haunted Cities in Florida

Are sellers required to disclose if a house is haunted?

No. In Florida, sellers are not required to disclose a property’s “haunted” status or whether a death occurred at the property, including murder or suicide. That’s why proactive research is key.

Will a house’s haunted reputation affect its value?

It can go either way. Some buyers pay a premium for historic and storied homes; others are deterred. Ultimately the impact depends on the property, neighborhood, and local buyer preferences.

How can I tell if a house’s haunting claims have a rational explanation?

Start with a professional inspection—plumbing, electrical, HVAC, pest, and structural. Many purported hauntings are explained by water leaks, drafts, wiring issues, or old pipes. Also research the property’s history using public records and local archives.

Should I be worried about safety if a house is rumored to be haunted?

Most ghost stories do not indicate physical danger. Your real safety priorities are the same as with any home—make sure the house is structurally sound, free of mold or environmental hazards, and compliant with code. If you have personal or spiritual concerns, consult a trusted advisor in your faith or community.

Can I sue a seller for not disclosing a haunting?

Whether you can pursue legal action depends on the specific facts and local law. Because Florida does not require disclosure of supernatural claims, a lawsuit is often difficult unless the seller actively concealed other material facts (like structural damage). If you have legal concerns, consult a real estate attorney.

Final Thoughts: Is Buying in the Haunted Cities in Florida Right for You?

Buying a property in one of the haunted cities in Florida can be exhilarating if you love history, story, and character. It can also be nerve-wracking if you’re the superstitious type or prefer turnkey, strictly factual transactions. My job as a realtor is to help you sort through the facts, separate folklore from function, and make a choice that blends your comfort level with a good investment strategy.

If you’re exploring a move to Florida, whether for the beaches, the culture, or because you want a home with a story to tell, I’m happy to help. My team and I take calls, texts, and emails daily from people making moves across South Florida. Whether you’re planning a move in a month or a year, let’s discuss what you want—haunted or otherwise—and find the right fit.

Reach out at 561-962-2865

Resources & Next Steps

• Visit local historical societies and archives in each city to verify stories and dates.
• Attend a guided ghost tour in St. Augustine or Key West to experience the local lore firsthand.
• Get a full property inspection—don’t rely on a haunted reputation to justify skipping this.
• Speak with neighbors, local business owners, and long-time residents to learn how the story has affected the neighborhood.
• Consult a real estate lawyer if legal questions arise about disclosure or past incidents.

Thanks for joining me on this spooky—and practical—tour of the top haunted cities in Florida. Whether you’re a skeptic, a history buff, or a paranormal enthusiast, Florida offers an incredible range of haunted homes and haunted neighborhoods. Stay curious, do your homework, and may the supernatural be ever in your favor—if that’s your thing. If you want help exploring properties in any of these cities, reach out—my team and I are here to help you make your best move yet.

Download Your FREE Relocation Guide